The aim of the FCA’s Consumer Investments Strategy, published on 15 September 2021, was to establish an investment market which gave confidence to potential investors and businesses looking for funding.
High-risk investments, however, can lead to significant losses and undermine the whole investment landscape, should the opportunity be misaligned with the investor’s risk tolerance.
Among others, the definition of high-risk investments includes speculative illiquid securities, crowdfunding peer-to-peer agreements, and non-mainstream pooled investments. It will now also include cryptoassets when they are brought within the financials promotions regime.
Since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic, the level of consumers holding high-risk investments has risen sharply. For example, the proportion of consumers owning cryptoassets increased 83% between March 2020 and June 2021. It is estimated that around three million people hold or have held ‘cryptocurrencies’ in the UK. The FCA have identified the need to use financial promotion rules to give consumers greater protections as research shows that consumers do not fully understand the risks involved. A study commissioned by the FCA found 45% of self-directed investors said they did not view ‘losing some money’ as a potential risk of investing. Another study, using 1,000 people, conducted by Opinium found 69% of those who purchased cryptoassets wrongly believed they are regulated by the FCA.
Currently, the FCA has limited powers to impose requirements on issuers of high-risk investments if the issuers of these products are unauthorised and not subject to the rules. However, if these investments are marketed, then they need to meet the requirements of the Financial Promotions statute.
Financial promotions take many forms, including print advertising, broadcast or online, websites, social media, brochures and emails.
At present, the Financial Promotions Regime consists of three core elements which combined, govern the marketing of financial services; Section 21 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA), FSMA (Financial Promotion) Order 2005 (FPO) and the FCA Handbook.
Authorised firms are able to market financial promotions on their own behalf or for unauthorised persons as long as they comply with the FCA Handbook rules. Indeed, unauthorised persons can market financial promotions if they comply within the rules of exemption in the FPO. Examples of such exemptions include communicating promotions to high-net-worth self-certified ‘sophisticated investors’.
Even if a financial promotion is not misleading, this may not be sufficient to protect consumers against the dangers of holding certain high-risk investments. For example, the product may still be inappropriate for most retail investors. Therefore, depending on the type of investment, the financial promotion rules apply varying levels of restrictions.
Cryptoassets and other related activities are currently outside the Financial Promotions Regime, so they are unlikely to have access to the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) or Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) if something goes wrong.
The FCA’s proposals to the Financial Promotions Regime
The FCA consultation paper CP22/2 represents the first proposed financial promotion rules for cryptoassets in the UK. Between April 2020 to March 2021, the FCA has taken enforcement action against two firms and four individuals, with fines totalling more than £300,000.
The proposals set out in CP22/2 seek to prevent harm to consumers from investing in high-risk investments that do not match their risk appetite. This in turn, helps preserve the integrity and confidence of the UK financial system. CP22/2 proposes to apply the following product categories for financial promotion marketing restrictions:

- Readily Realisable Securities (RRS);
- Restricted Mass Market Investments (RMMI); and
- Non-Mass Market Investments (NMMI).
RRS are defined as listed or exchange traded securities. For example, share or bonds listed on the London Stock Exchange. It is proposed that no restrictions will apply under the financial promotion rules.
RMMI can refer to shares or bonds in a company not listed on an exchange and peer-to-peer agreements. The proposals in CP22/2 will allow these investments to be marketed to retail consumers, with certain restrictions as liquidity to sell these investments will not be as frequent compared to RRS products.
The consumer in receipt of such a promotion must be categorised as either a certified high-net-worth investor, a certified sophisticated investor, a self-certified sophisticated investor or a certified ‘restricted’ investor. For the latter, the individual must sign a declaration to say they have not in the last 12 months, and will not in the next 12 months invest more than 10% of their net assets into these type of investments.
In addition, firms must comply with the FCA Handbook rules on appropriateness (COBS 10/10A), where firms need to consider the investor’s knowledge and experience in the relevant investment field to enable an assessment of whether the product is appropriate for that investor.
It should also be noted that the FCA proposes that cryptoassets will be categorised as RMMI products. This requires the Treasury to confirm their intentions to amend the controlled investments and controlled activities defined in Schedule 1 of the FPO to include ‘qualifying cryptoassets’. Therefore, mass-marketing of cryptoassets to retail consumers will be permitted, subject to meeting the requirements of the financial promotion rules.
NMMI products include speculative illiquid securities and Non-Mainstream Pooled Investments (NMPI) such as pooled investments in an unauthorised fund. Mass marketing to retail investors is banned for these types of products. Therefore, authorised firms can only market these investments where an exemption to the marketing restrictions applies, including for certified high-net-worth individuals, certified sophisticated and self-certified sophisticated investors.
This requires the firm to acquaint itself with the investor’s profile and objectives to determine whether the investment is likely to be suitable.
CP22/2 aims to make the following improvements to assist and strengthen the consumer investment journey, particularly for RMMI and NMMI products:
- improve risk warnings to help consumers better understand the products;
- ban inducements to invest to prevent investments not being aligned with the investor’s risk tolerance;
- add positive frictions to the consumer journey to support more considered investment decisions and counter social and emotional pressures to invest in higher risk investments;
- assist consumers to better categorise themselves with the adoption of high-net-worth, sophisticated or restricted investors; and
- strengthen appropriateness tests so consumers can assess their knowledge and experience.
These are baseline protections and firms should consider going beyond these requirements, for example, providing educational material to potential investors.
CP22/2 proposes to give firms three months to comply with the final rules once they come into force. Current investor declarations are only valid for 12 months, so firms will be required to use the new declaration if they wish to make further direct financial promotions for RMMI or for NMMI to existing customers once existing certificates have expired.
With respect to cryptoassets, because they are not currently subject to financial promotion rules (until ‘qualifying cryptoassets’ are confirmed in statute as proposed by the Treasury), firms need to ensure customers are categorised appropriately and an appropriateness test is undertaken to existing and new customers wanting to participate in these products.
When an authorised firm communicates a financial promotion, it must ensure that it complies with the financial promotion rules in COBS 4. Authorised third parties can also communicate the financial promotions if they confirm compliance, only communicate to intended recipients and the promotion is fair, clear and not misleading.
Firms are also required to include a new date stamp for new promotions and ongoing monitoring requirements is necessary. In addition, CP22/2 intends to extend the conflicts of interest obligations for firms approving financial promotions for unauthorised persons and for those confirming compliance for an authorised firm.
This is particularly acute for the cryptoassets sector as most of these firms are unauthorised, and will need to have their financial promotions approved by an authorised firm with relevant experience.
The team at OSS Consult has proven in-depth knowledge of the legal and regulatory obligations under the Financial Promotions Order and outlined in COBS 4, and a wealth of practical experience of implementing Financial Promotions frameworks for authorised firms including policies, procedures and checklists.
If you have concerns that your firm’s Financial Promotions framework is inadequate and/or would like a review of your current framework in order to be prepared for the proposals set out in CP22/2, please contact Rod Martenstyn, rod@ossconsult.co.uk .
Kuldeep Gill