Proposed changes to improve the appointed representative regime

In part spurred on by the Greensill Capital Securities fiasco, the Treasury Select Committee explored and discovered that the Appointed Representative Regime, which was established in 1986, could well be being used for purposes well beyond the original remit.

The ensuing report proposed the FCA and Treasury investigate reforming the regime in order to lessen any potential harm to consumers and markets by limiting the regime’s scope and reducing opportunities for abusing the system.

A number of proposals have been laid down in the FCA’s Consultation Paper CP21/34 which include pronounced, weighty and significant changes that are intended to make it more onerous to appoint an Appointed Representative (AR), with the aim of drastically reducing the abuse of the regime.
The Treasury need to be involved in this process due to the AR model being initially established by legislation (FSMA 2000 (Appointed Representatives) Regulations 2001), so they will need to check whether or not legislative change is required.

The proposals being put forward are considered necessary to reduce and/or prevent any harm being experienced by the consumer and markets.
Currently what is being seen is some ARs submitting misleading information or information that is difficult for consumers to comprehend.

There are products and/or services not delivering the benefits that consumers anticipate. As well as this, consumers have products aimed at them that are unsuitable.

Some principal firms are culpable of failing to having sufficient compliance oversight of their ARs aside to possessing inadequate controls over the ARs’ regulated activities executed on their principal firm’s behalf.

Several harms and damages are not being identified or appropriately acted on.

Several ARs, it has been discovered, have been acting outside of their appointment and the proposals also want to reduce and/or cut out any other practices which impede the consumer.

These situations arise primarily because the principal firm has not performed enough due diligence before appointing an AR as is required under SUP 12, because the principal performs inadequate controls and reviews post the appointment and/or that the principal firm has too many ARs to oversee and control. It is the hope that the new and somewhat at times arduous measures being proposed will reduce the amount of ARs any one principal firm would be willing to appoint.

So, the proposals intend to achieve more targeted regulatory supervision, as mentioned before making the process more laborious, imposing stronger information obligations upon the principal firms along with having to provide more detailed information of the existing and potential new ARs on the financial services register.

The principal firms will also be compelled to complete annual self-certifications of compliance.
Upon investigation, it revealed that between 50 and 400 percent more complaints were received across all sectors about principal firms with ARs than other directly authorised firms.

Any questions, issues or objections to the proposals set out in CP21/34 were due to be submitted to the FCA by 3 March 2022.

The FCA’s proposals require additional information on Appointed Representatives on top of what is already in place. These need to be submitted within 60 calendar days of the implementation of the new rules for existing ARs and at least if not more than 60 calendar days before the appointment of a new AR.

The four key markers of new information required by principal firms are:

  1. The AR’s business model.
  2. The AR’s revenue.
  3. Any and all complaints that may have been set forth against the AR alone where currently the information is muddled because it’s aggregated along with the principal firm.
  4. The AR’s regulated and non-regulated business activities.

On top of this the FCA will expect principal firms to provide the following information on their ARs:

  • The primary reason for wanting to appoint the particular AR.
  • The regulated business it will permit the AR to undertake on its behalf.
  • Its non-regulated business.
  • Whether or not the AR will be providing services to retail customers.
  • Whether or not the AR was working with a different principal firm previously and if so, why the change.
  • Whether the AR is part of a group.
  • Whether or not an individual will be contracted to the principal firm in order to execute portfolio management and/or dealing activities.
  • The financial agreement between the principal firm and the AR.
  • The foreseeable revenue from all activity during the AR’s first year.

Any changes to the AR’s information regarding the name or categories of the regulated activities that the principal firm permits the AR to carry out on its behalf will be required to be submitted to the FCA at least 10 calendar days before any said changes.

Any other alterations to the AR’s information will need to be put forth at least 10 business days prior to the event.

The principal firms will need to perform annual reviews of their ARs, another issue that will more than likely lead to less ARs being appointed. These reviews will have to include the fitness and respectability of the AR, its financial situation, the capacity and wherewithal of the persons undertaking the regulated activities within it and the sufficiency of the firm’s controls and resources.

Any significant or major changes to the AR would lead to more regular reviews being necessary.
These changes will most likely force the hands of the principal firms to warrant the introduction of contractual obligations upon the AR to notify them of any changes to their circumstances allowing the principal firm to inform the FCA within the time limits.

Finally, a great deal less information will be required of the much more limited Introducer Appointed Representative, which in turn could well prove to be more appealing to the principal firm.

The team at OSS Consult has proven in-depth knowledge of the regulatory obligations under SUP 12 and a wealth of practical experience of implementing compliance frameworks for principal firms with Appointed Representatives, which includes specific AR Risk Assessments and AR Compliance Monitoring Programmes.

If you have concerns that your principal firm’s control framework for its AR(s) is inadequate and/or would like a review of your current control framework in order to be prepared for the proposals set out in CP21/34, please contact Rod Martenstyn, rod@ossconsult.co.uk or Chris Watts chris@ossconsult.co.uk .

Chris Watts
Chris@ossconsult.co.uk