Following an investigation undertaken by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) into retail banking, searching for ways to improve the services delivered to consumers and small and medium sized businesses alike, open banking was introduced to the UK in 2017. The notion was to have a system in place whereby consumers and businesses would not have lengthy and laborious issues, such as mass paperwork, if and when the consumer wished to interact with other services that require certain financial information from them; a system that would enable them to share, safely and securely, their financial details such as transaction history data with trusted third parties. It was also envisaged that it would empower several beneficial money management companies to provide a bespoke service to the consumer, with tailored recommendations to save money.
So, the CMA ordered the largest nine UK banks and building societies to initialise and build the Open Banking Implementation and Financial Entity (OBIE). Then the nine largest banks were Lloyds, Barclays, Nationwide, RBS, Santander, Danske Bank, HSBC, Allied Irish Banks and Bank of Ireland and this was to be titled the CMA9.
The system became a great success and presently the UK is a global leader in Open Banking with an estimated 5.5 million individuals and as many as half of UK small businesses using servers powered by Open Banking technology.
But it did not get to this point without some major issues, uncovered after an investigation into the management of the OBIE, post allegations submitted in 2020.
To undertake the investigation, the CMA appointed a non-executive with experience in Corporate Governance and with zero association with the organisations being investigated.
The five areas targeted for thorough examination were:
- Corporate Governance
- Late Delivery of Accounts
- Management of Conflicts
- Procurement and Value for Money
- Human Resources
The investigation uncovered some serious issues within the OBIE including bullying, harassment, discrimination, and victimisation.
It was brought to light that the Trustee had not been appraising the management of the OBIE, therefore lack of discipline was allowed to flourish. Also, amongst several other issues, the investigation concluded that an absence of suitable governance directly added to the non-professional environment.
Finally, the investigation culminated that the CMA plus the nine retails banks must accept their share of blame. There should have been more galvanised mechanisms for governance from the very beginning. There was an absence of surveillance to issues of governance, and there was nothing in place to refine the governance once it became clear that the entity was becoming more complex and much more prolonged than was initially expected.
Post the findings, the Trustee tendered his resignation and was replaced. New non-executive directors were appointed to furnish independent research and support.
Prior to this issue being cleared up, on 25 March 2022, the CMA, the FCA, the Payment Systems Regulator (PSR) and HMT announced the forming of a Joint Regulatory Oversight Committee (JROC), to be co-chaired by the FCA’s executive director for consumers and competition, and the PSR’s managing director.
The initial meeting of the JROC was held on 12 May 22, whereby the Terms of Reference for the committee were established. The roles decided on were:
- Supervise the planning and construction of the future Open Banking entity.
- Supervise the transition to the future structure.
- To look for, and seize on, any opportunities or brainwaves that can lead to an embellishment of open banking and to develop a strategy for further developing open banking.
- To keep track of and oversee the future entity until a permanent regulatory framework is established.
Believing the budding opportunity of building on the already flourishing open banking scenario, the thinking is of creating further benefits for consumers and businesses alike. The committee see development and improvement in open banking payments, end-users’ ability to share data, management of access and development of data sharing concepts.
In addition, the committee will consider and action on greater consumer protection and make certain that open banking will continue to be compatible with any future open banking commencements.
The committee emphasised their desire to work in close partnership with the industry and other key shareholders, this led to them deciding to muster a Strategic Working Group (SWG).
An independent chair of the SWG has been appointed and will report directly to the co-chairs of the JROC, any findings, ideas or recommendations deriving from the SWG meetings.
The SWG is a non-decision-making assembly whereby the views of the industry, consumers, businesses, and other stakeholders, along with any input they may have into the future development of open banking, can be aired.
The SWG is due to run from August to December 2022 when all views, ideas and proposals will be collated and presented to the JROC.
It’s clear to see that Open Banking is considered to be the way forward by many financial institutions and bodies, and that the improvement and embellishment is very much at the forefront of their objectives.
For more information or detail on Open Banking, please contact either myself, chris@occconsult.co.uk or rod@ossconsult.co.uk
Chris Watts October 2022