Following on from our April 2023 article on IFPR, post a review, the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) have published their supplementary observations regarding how firms are implementing requirements on the Internal Capital Adequacy and Risk Assessment (ICARA) process and reporting under the IFPR.
Included in their report are summaries by the regulator on good and substandard practices being employed by firms and they are advising that firms solidly consider how they can strengthen their operations and processes.
The IFPR process applies to all MiFID (Markets in Financial Instruments Directive), firms and will be of interest to companies such as:
- Fund and Asset Managers
- Investment Platforms
- Firms that deal on a proprietary basis
- Depositaries
- Securities Brokers
The ICARA process enables firms to identify any risk of harm that their operations could potentially cause to markets and consumers alike (as well as to the firm itself) and give them the opportunity to administer appropriate resources and controls in order to mitigate them. This applies to both ongoing business activities and when the firm winds down its business.
This review by the FCA is aimed at supporting firms as they adapt to the new prudential standards by conducting a cross-sector, multi-firm examination who are adopting the new regulatory regime, including the conduct of their ICARA processes.
The FCA focused on:
- Capital Adequacy
- Liquidity Adequacy
- Wind-Down Planning
They also perused how firms were reporting under MIFIDPRU.
If all of the above are duly considered, managed and structured, firms should be able to demonstrate to consumers and markets that they can be confident in the knowledge that firms will be capable to address any potential harms that could arise from their operations, mitigate them and reduce/eradicate harm in firm failure.
After reviewing, the FCA concluded that firms have been making progress in comprehending the requirements of the new regime, noticing that firms have been purposefully considering and seeking to mitigate any harms the firm’s operations can create.
However, the regulator did discover some areas for improvement, some of these were as follows:
- It was noted that a fair number of firms did not apply ample consideration to cashflows and liquidity stresses, which in turn evoked an inadequate assessment of liquid asset requirements. This means, that in times of market stress, the firm could easily run out of cash, in turn possibly causing the firm to fail.
- Most firms internal intervention points were inefficiently designed which could/would lead to actions to mitigate any harm not being triggered in time, again potentially resulting in firm failure.
- Firms did not pay enough attention to all members of a group of firms, meaning that if any of the individual firms employed inadequate planning, then that could, and probably would, have an impact upon the entire group.
- Several firms possessed notable failings in their application of capital models for operational risk. This provides little or no assurance that they have adequate resources to mitigate harm.
Firms must understand to what extent their own funds and liquid assets could be exhausted under stressed conditions and over what time scale. Firms must, in addition, include plans for mitigating on-going stress. The danger could be, that while preparations are being made and/or a wind-down plan is instigated, the company’s resources may have depleted to such an extent that there would no longer be sufficient funds to execute an orderly wind-down.
Firms are also expected to be certain of and comprehend exactly where internal points of intervention and actions should be set through stress-testing and to maintain a resource buffer to assist in managing their financial resources.
So, some key points for firms to be aware of and ensure they are meeting standards and requirements:
LIQUID ASSET REQUIREMENT ASSESSMENTS
As touch upon earlier, firms were unprepared to immediately address liquidity strains under stressed conditions.
The FCA noted that firms were assessing their liquid asset requirements through the ICARA process, but some did not satisfactorily apply the guidance of MIFIDPRU to consider periods of financial stress.
It is expected of firms to be able to produce a rational estimate of the amount of liquid assets they would require to reinforce on-going operation, including under stressed conditions, or indeed to implement an orderly wind-down.
Firms must observe that liquidity stresses have an instant impact, leaving them little or no time find alternative courses of action. It is vital that firms hold sufficient liquid assets to underpin them and meet their financial obligations under stressed market conditions.
Below are some points the regulator noted that firms lacked consideration of:
- Assessing Cashflows
- Applying relevant stresses
- Ensuring they apply more than just a subset of liquidity stresses
- Employing real severity and variety of stresses as encountered in recent times
- Applying forward-looking assessments
- Regularly reviewing and adjusting, (where necessary), stress assessments.
- Applying time-granular analysis of cashflows
- Distinguishing between liquid assets and own funds
EARLY WARNING INDICATORS, TRIGGERS & INTERVENTIONS
These enable firms to identify if and when their resilience is diminishing. If their indicators and triggers are incorrectly set, the firm will react too late to intervene and mitigate harm. MIFIDPRU also specifies the need for an early warning indicator (EWI), for own funds and wind-down triggers which require notifications to and may result in FCA intervention
Firms are also anticipated to determine their own internal framework for managing financial resources harmoniously with their own analysis and assessments from the ICARA process. Firms should contemplate severe but plausible stresses in order to realise the appropriate level of resources when internal action is taken upon themselves.
WIND-DOWN PLANS, GROUP CONSIDERATIONS
Firms have been observed to possess a lack of knowledge regarding all individual firms in a group. There were several instances where group dependencies were not taken into account and therefore the resulting assessment would not be accurate for an orderly wind-down, primarily because the resources would not be available.
The wind-down assessment needs to include information regarding shared systems throughout the entire group and all costs and resources need to be observed.
Group governance was also an issue that materialised. The involvement of all governance must be lucid and also group-wide risk appetite is a requirement for acceptable assessment. Individual plans within the group did not take into consideration other group members plans, resulting in inconsistencies.
Aside from the problems with group wind-down plans, other matters included many instances where the wind-down plans had not even been updated for several years and there were examples of plans and cost assumptions that were out of synchronisation. As if that wasn’t enough, there were also occasions where the trigger for the activation of a wind-down was assumed under normal market conditions and not stressed circumstances, plus the omission of inclusion of the possibility that liquid assets and own funds could well be depleted due to a prior stress environment.
OPERATIONAL-RISK CAPITAL ASSESSMENT
Here it was observed that there were examples of firms not thoroughly taking into account the risks sustained. A number of risk approaches were over complicated regarding the allotment of risk and harm, resulting in poor assessments of adequate resources. Others used assumptions that were not wholly demonstrated or explained.
There were also examples of model executions including errors such as code errors, incorrect estimates of inputs and/or inputting errors.
Finally, some group models were employed by individual firms without substantiating the appropriateness of the application by checking against the firm’s individual model risk governance.
A CONCISE GUIDE TO GOOD ICARA PRACTICES
| ICARA PROCESS |
| Ensure inclusion of clear consistencies in analysis of own funds, liquid assets, wind-down planning and stress testing |
| Complete a holistic assessment of harm from the firm’s operations |
| Ensure that ICARA assessments are integrated with each other |
| Consider the resource assessment when assessing threshold requirements when wind-down planning |
| GROUP ICARAS |
| Present clear assessments of each individual firm’s risks when completing the group ICARA |
| Include all activities and costs of each individual firm when creating a group wind-down plan |
| Ensure the allocation of numbers appropriate to each individual firm |
| Include specific actions required to wind-down each individual firm within the group wind-down plan |
| Ensure prior agreement with FCA when processing ICARA on a ‘consolidated basis’ |
| EARLY WARNING INDICATORS, TRIGGERS & INTERVENTIONS |
| Ensure all frameworks are based on the behaviour of financial resources under stress |
| Use insights from stress testing when initiating a resource buffer & include a time limit for making decisions when the buffer is breached |
| Identify internal early warning indicators before the point of critical stress |
| Appraise the recovery plan & wind-down triggers to aid in deciding excess resources needed to be held |
| Utilise recent market stress events when stress testing |
| Clearly identify & communicate actions required at each intervention point |
| Show that the firm has a clear understanding of its risk |
| Include own assessment of own funds & liquid assets required within the metrics monitored |
| Ensure at least adequate assessment of risk & indicate the risk appetite, trigger & limit framework & choice of stress scenarios |
| Utilise reverse stress-testing |
| Clarify whether intervention points either lead to discussions, trigger specific actions or instigate further actions such as a wind-down plan |
| Show that the firm recognises that resources could continue to reduce whilst discussions are underway & that there are provisions in place should this occur |
| Use stress-testing effectively so as to identify how much more resources would be necessary should thresholds be exceeded |
| ASSESSMENT OF LIQUID ASSET REQUIREMENTS |
| Assess cash requirements under normal & stressed conditions |
| Liquidity stresses should include market-wide strain as well as firm-specific |
| Rigorously consider activities, exposures & obligations specific to the firm when choosing liquidity stresses |
| Assessment of liquidity risk should involve intra-day, inter-day, weekly & monthly projections of cash-flows under stress |
| Ensure time intervals are granular enough when analysing stressed cash flows |
| Make regular reviews of stress assessments to ensure proactive adjustments as and when necessary |
| Apply forward-looking assessments as required by MIFIDPRU |
| Ensure consideration of severity of liquidity stresses in alignment with recent stresses and volatility in relevant markets |
| OPERATIONAL RISK CAPITAL ASSESSMENTS |
| Display clear linkage between enterprise risk assessment, the risk control self-assessment process, scenario analysis & operational risk assessment |
| Exclude any consolidation across different legal entities when assessing operational risk for an individual entity |
| Evaluate the limitations of operational risk models |
| Have in place model risk governance |
| Have a policy of regular independent validation of operational risk models |
| If part of a larger firm group, individual firms should ensure group operational risk models are fit for purpose when going through an individual ICARA process |
| Do not over-complicate methodologies around the attribution of risks and harm |
| WIND-DOWN PLANNING PROCESS |
| Use a backdrop of stress to find the level of resources required |
| Thoroughly cover requirements of the firm’s operations, including products, geographies, activities and obligations specific to the firm |
| Detailed enough to identify business as usual costs, wind-down driven costs and cashflow mismatches |
| Plans should be tested through simulations |
| The framework for managing resources should be comprehensive |
| In addition to triggers on capital & liquidity, non-financial triggers should be included |
| Consider the order that affected legal entities will be wound-down when part of a group |
| Ensure wind-down plans and costs are aligned |
| Be sure to update plans on a regular basis |
| Be realistic with assumptions |
| USEABILITY OF THE ICARA DOCUMENT AND PROCESS |
| Clearly highlight the bases and drivers of threshold requirements & the appetite & trigger framework used to manage financial resources |
| Display a clear record of scenarios, assumptions, analysis, conclusions & decisions made |
| Display an itemised breakdown of risk calculated |
| Display a clear picture of key changes in the assessments since the previous iteration |
If you would like further or mor detailed information regarding IFPR, please contact either chris@ossconsult.co.uk or rod@ossconsult.co.uk
Chris Watts
December 2023